Samuel Phillips Verner in the Kasai
by Gordon D. Gibson
Smithsonian Institution

What student of African cultures, upon seeing an impressive old African ancestor figure or a much-worn ritual mask displayed in a museum case, has not wondered how the collector managed to abstract such a valuable item from its original owners, from those who treasured it for its religious significance or its magical power rather than for the exotic or artistic quality attributed to it by outsiders. Was it given to the collector so that he could invoke the magic or appeal to the ancestor represented? Not very likely. Was it alienated [?] in exchange for services, goods, or money? Or was it perhaps stolen? And if acquired by exchange, did the seller really have the right to dispose of a ritual object that may have belonged to a social group — a family, a clan, or a whole tribe? (The writer was once told by a missionary doctor who had served for years and years in Liberia that many of the objects he acquired and eventually deposited in museums had been brought to him in the dead of the night at the hospital by people who wished to sell them secretly, because they feared serious objections if their families were to learn of the transactions.)

While many of the older major museums contain important early collections of African ethnography (important both because they were often accompanied by good primary documentation and because the collections were made before the era of extensive production for the art market), insufficient attention has been paid to the circumstances under which the collecting was done. Only rarely does the collector indicate in detail how he persuaded the original owners to part with their treasures. In lieu of direct information about the mode of collecting, one can attempt to discover the nature of the relationship that existed between the field collector and the people who were willing to trade their images or equipment. In studying the publications, notes, and correspondence left by an early collector, one is often able to learn of the circumstances by which certain items came into his possession. More rarely these documents reveal not only the particulars of the transactions but also information about the significance and symbolism of the objects themselves — rarely because this usually depends upon the collector's having a truly anthropological interest and sufficient background to enable him to ask significant questions and to understand the responses. More often the best the latter-day researcher can do with a collector's records is to establish the general nature of the relationship that existed between him and his hosts.

It was with the hope of finding additional documentation that I began to study the publications, notes, and correspondence left by and about Samuel Phillips Verner, an enthusiastic amateur ethnologist who provided African ethnographic collections to at least three American museums. In 1895 Verner had been sent by a Presbyterian mission society to what was then the Congo Free State; and in 1899 he brought a collection of some two to three hundred items from the Kasai region to the Smithsonian Institution. He provided tribal attributions for most of the items and places of acquisition for some, but not much more in the way of documentation. The Smithsonian has a copy of Verner’s book, Pioneering in Central Africa, and also copies of some of his published articles on life in the Congo Free State along with a few faded photographs and some notes left by the Curator (Walter Hough) who met with Verner at the time when the collection was accessioned, but little more. Tracing the fascinating details of this man’s life has turned out to be a treasure hunt, with new clues and occasional substantial discoveries of useful information revealed at many stations along the way. Not a great deal more primary documentation of items in the Verner collections has emerged, but we do now have a much better appreciation of the man’s motives and of the nature of his interest in Central Africa and of his relationship with the Africans who helped him.

Verner’s activities in Africa were wide ranging, encompassing those of missionary, explorer, anthropologist, and developer. His important contribution to the ethnological collections of the Smithsonian Institution derived from the early missionary phase of his life, a phase during which his anthropological sensibilities were forming while at the same time his attention was being increasingly drawn to the educational and developmental needs and the commercial possibilities of Central Africa. The collections that he assembled for the American Museum of Natural History (transmitted by Frederick Starr) and for the Putnam Museum in Davenport, Iowa, were made on a later trip, at a time when he thought of himself primarily as an anthropologist rather than as a missionary.

Born in 1873 in South Carolina, Samuel P. Verner grew up in a family with a long tradition of scholarly pursuit. His grandfather had been President of the University of North Carolina and an uncle, Samuel Phillips, served as Solicitor General of the United States under every administration from Grant to Cleveland (1872-85). Verner graduated at the top of his class from the South Carolina College (later to become the University of South Carolina) where he was described as a brilliant but overly intense student. He taught school for a year in South Carolina, but the increasing pressures of academic life led him to seek relief for a time in more manual occupations, and he went to work in the carpentry shops of the Southern Railway for a period of nine months. During this short time he received nine promotions and learned much about railway engines — knowledge that he later called upon in Africa, first to solve practical problems with steam engines and later to explore for the extension of the rail lines in the Congo. In his spare time he read books on African adventure, including every available work of Livingstone and Stanley, and was much moved by Livingstone’s appeal for missionary workers to carry ahead the task of Christian instruction in Central Africa. In 1893 Verner went to Tuscaloosa, Alabama, where an uncle was Superintendent of the Stillman Institute, a small industrial training school for Blacks sponsored by the Presbyterian Church. There the young man helped with the school and engaged in various Christian and welfare services.

At that time the Presbyterian Church had already established a mission, founded in 1892 by S. N. Lapsley and W. H. Sheppard at Luebo in the Kasai District where both Black and White missionaries labored. The conditions were severe, the workers few, and the Church was making strong appeals for new missionaries. Phillips Verner, as he was known to his friends, answered the call. He already had formulated some ideas about African needs and the proper course of African development and a conviction that this could best be brought about with American involvement. He was motivated not only by religious zeal, but also, as he put it, by a desire “… to assist in the great task of educating and leading a backward people.”

Normally Presbyterian ministers required a four-year college course and a three-year seminary course before being ordained. But the Executive Committee for Foreign Missions badly needed men and decided to examine young Verner at once upon the basis of his general college education. Passing stiff tests in Latin, Greek, Mental and Moral Philosophy, Rhetoric, Natural Science, Theology, Church History, Church Government, and the Sacraments, Verner was licensed to preach and was ordained a minister the same day. In an autobiographical sketch written late in his life, Verner says that he had no intention of associating himself permanently with the missionary organization and agreed to undertake to manage the business aspects of a mission group for up to three years, only if it was understood that he would be released from obligation at the end of that period. It appears from Verner’s letters home and his early published writings, however, that he was not only a devout Christian but an enthusiastic proselytizer, even when in the company of rough seamen on board the ships that took him from America to Africa. And while in the service of the Mission Society, far from eschewing missionary activity, he attempted to found a new mission station. Later, however, he rejected the title “Reverend,” claiming that he was only a “lay missionary.” But this is getting ahead of the story.

Verner and another neophyte, Joseph Phipps, a Caribbean Black who had immigrated to Pennsylvania, sailed together from New York in 1895 for London where they acquired suitable tropical outfits and visited several old Congo hands. They left England from Liverpool on a ship bound for Matadi on the Lower Congo River, with brief stops at Madeira, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Gold Coast, Cameroon, some coastal trading stations north of the Congo mouth, and small trading ports on the lower stretches of the Congo River.

Verner’s assignment included handling the business affairs of the Presbyterian Mission, dealing with the Congo Free State government, and managing the transport service from Matadi to the Mission station 1000 miles inland at Luebo. He found it necessary to remain at Matadi for six months to reorganize the handling of the mail and trade goods destined for the Mission in the interior. During this period he moved the forwarding station from Lukungu, a way-station on the trail from Matadi to Stanley Pool, to the railhead at Tumba Gare, nearly halfway to Leopoldville, and stationed Phipps there as agent. In February of 1896 Verner made a brief trip to Luanda, the capital of Angola, to investigate the possibility of establishing a sanitarium where missionaries might recover from the effects of malaria and other illnesses that plagued all who worked in Central Africa. Though nothing came of this effort, the trip did allow Verner to extend his knowledge of the coastal zone of West Central Africa.

Before leaving Matadi for the establishment at Luebo, Verner typed out a fourteen-page letter to the Mission Committee giving his thoughts, by this time well-formulated, on the various Protestant societies in the Congo, their problems, frustrations, and failings. He was especially critical of the lack of unity and cooperation among them. As to the Presbyterian Mission, he thought it suffered from sending Black ministers, for they were not given the same consideration by the Congo State authorities that White missionaries received. He believed, however, that American Blacks were especially well-suited to work in Africa because of their resistance to solar exposure and malaria, their “phlegmatic temperament,” and other psychological factors, and he judged they would be especially successful in teaching and preaching. Verner urged that the men sent out be competent in French, pleaded for a real medical doctor, and suggested alternating terms of service in Africa and the U.S. for the missionaries. In this report Verner clearly revealed a Southern bias — a belief in innate White superiority linked with the opinion that “… the Colored people reared in the South [i.e., under Southern White tutorship] were the best representatives of their race.”

In August of 1896 Verner began the journey to the Luebo Mission deep in the interior. he rode the train as far as it went; then, after a visit to the railway construction site, he hiked on to Stanley Pool with a company of porters to carry his gear, a trip requiring a week’s time. At Leopoldville, already a sizable community, he learned how to make bricks at the American Baptist Mission while waiting for the river steamer. When it arrived he saw it loaded with supplies and trade goods to be carried up the Kasai to Luebo. The trip up the river from Kinshasa required nearly a month, but even then the river steamer went only as far as the confluence of the Kasai with the Lulua where it deposited Verner with a ton of goods to be moved overland to the Mission, some days’ journey ahead. Bearers were sent from Luebo to carry the goods and to lead the neophyte to his new home. The previous business manager of the Luebo Mission, Dr. D. W. Snyder, a pharmacist by profession, had left the station shortly before with his wife who was very ill. At Luebo Verner was warmly welcomed by the Reverend Sheppard and the other missionaries, all of whom were American Blacks. Nearby was a state post, some foreign trading establishments, and several large villages of two tribes — Kete and Bena Lulua. Settled also around the Mission were some Nsapo (Zapo-Zap) people and many Luba, most of whom, says Verner, were the recently freed slaves of Portuguese traders who had formerly lived at Luebo. Nearby, along the river, were villages of Mbuya, a Kete sub-tribe of fishermen who also supported themselves by producing pottery for sale [Verner, 1903, pp. 403-5]. Verner found himself in charge of the mundane activities of the establishment and involved in its spiritual side as well. He set to work to learn about the local people and the system of interaction that had grown up between them and the Mission personnel, and he began to study the Luba language. He was discouraged by what seemed to him to be the lack of an orderly system of operating the Mission, and at first much of his time and energy had to be devoted to the transport of supplies and of goods needed for exchange with the native peoples. The Mission was wholly dependent upon the State steamer, which was generally filled to capacity with material needed at the official posts and therefore unable to transport the supplies that had piled up at Stanley Pool and were desperately needed for the daily operation of the Luebo station. In numerous letters home, Verner urged the Missions Committee to provide a steamer for the missions, advice they finally acted upon only after Verner’s return to America.

Verner does not tell us when his interest in collecting examples of Congolese artistry and artisanship commenced. The Reverend W. H. Sheppard, one of the founders of the Luebo Mission and still its spiritual leader, had been the first outsider to visit the Bushongo Kuba in 1892, and had become fascinated by their civilization [Sheppard, 1916]. Sheppard made a significant collection of the artistry of the Kuba and neighboring peoples that eventually went to the Hampton Institute, and his interest in these products of Central African civilization may well have stimulated Verner to follow his example.

In about March of 1897, after Verner had been at Luebo for half a year or so and long enough for him to learn the Luba language sufficiently well enough to use in his sermons, an agent of a Belgian trading firm brought him word that Ndombe, whom Verner called the “King” of the Bena Bikenge (or Bieeng) and who was chief of the Wissmann Falls District, wished the missionaries to visit him. The commercial agent recommended Ndombe’s town as a likely site for a new mission. In fact, Ndombe soon thereafter sent a delegation of some two dozen men headed by Djoka, his prime minister, to urge Verner to undertake the journey and to provide him with an armed escort. Though the Kete people of the Luebo region protested that only they should act as middlemen in dealings between the missionaries and Ndombe, Verner brushed these objections aside and prepared to go. With an entourage of about eighty people, including bearers to carry his camping equipment, a hammock to be used in crossing streams, supplies for several weeks, and some goods to trade, the party set out for Ndombe’s town. The Lulua was crossed by canoes, and smaller streams by canoe or by wading, but not without resistance from some villagers along the route who were fearful of the consequences of allowing a White man to enter their country. In crossing what Verner calls the “Biomba Plain” Verner’s party arrived at a village of the Bena Biombo under a Chief Tambu at a time when the boys’ initiation festival was in progress. It may well have been there that Verner acquired two magnificent examples of the chameleon-eyed muluala masks (figures 1 and 2) that are characteristic of the Biombo art style, though there is no mention of them in his book [cf. Himmelheber, 1960, p. 354 and figure 277]. After passing a night in Tambu’s town, the caravan proceeded toward the Biombo capital, the town of the paramount Chief Chimbundu. Before they reached that point, they were met by a welcoming party from Ndombe’s capital, still twenty miles away, led by the King’s arms-bearer and bringing baskets of food, bunches of bananas, and gourds of foaming palm wine. Chief Chimbundu’s town was guarded by fetish sticks planted alongside the path leading into it; and a kind of gateway erected on the path, consisting of two posts with a crosspiece overhead, bristled with arrows that had been shot into it, a warning to any who passed by that the place was strongly defended. (One such gateway was surmounted by a stuffed monkey [Verner, 1899, p. 26]).

Verner, in a general discussion of the region, notes that sticks with red-colored heads carved upon them were erected in the countryside at points where paths crossed and also were set up in towns at various places. “… no particular skill is shown in the carving, nor does any great reverence appear to attach to them,” he writes, “as, when I once bought one, in five minutes nearly everyone in the village was broken off and offered for sale.” [Verner 1903, pp. 311-12. See also Himmelheber, loc. cit., and figure 279]. Three small figures brought back by Verner appear to be in the Biombo style and may also have been acquired on this first trip to Biombo country. One, an elongated head with conical eyes (figure 00), was plainly cut from the top of a pole. The other two are simpler still, though one is carved with a bust, and both retain portions of their support posts.

After a night spent in Chimbundu’s town, the Biombo chief volunteered to provide not only an escort but bearers to carry Verner in his hammock to Ndombe’s capital. A passage over some hills and through a fertile valley with fields of manioc eventually brought the party to their destination, where Djoka and Verner, now afoot for the grand entrance, led the caravan into Ndombe’s headquarters. Verner describes it as “the finest town I had yet seen” and “a marvel of cleanliness and order.” After leading Verner to his own house and supplying him with food and palm wine, Djoka left him for a few minutes, but soon returned with the King. Verner’s description is most vivid:

The man whose gigantic form loomed up in the gateway of Djoka’s yard made an instantaneous impression of the kind that is never forgotten. He came alone, but he would have been a marked man in a thousand. I had never seen a man, White or Black, of the toute-ensemble which he presented. It was needless to ask who this was; every movement and feature proclaimed him a king among men. This was the far-famed Ndombe himself, who came quietly up to the shed where I was sitting, and held out his right hand, saying, ‘Mukelenge, moiyo!’ (‘O King, life!’)… He was nearly six-feet and a half in stature; of a bright copper color; with broad shoulders, Herculean limbs, and massive statuesque features. The physical build of the man conveyed a distinct impression of great power. [Verner, 1903, pp. 166-68.]

Djoka made the traditional gift of blue beads to the Chief, a custom with which Verner was not yet acquainted, intended to symbolize acknowledgment of the Chief’s official position. The King invited Verner to his own apartments and the royal reception room, reached only by walking through a labyrinth of passageways between high walls. He at once asked Verner to explain his missionary work, and Verner did this at length, speaking in the Luba tongue, which Ndombe understood well. Impressed by Verner’s statement that Biblical teachings stressed truthfulness, Ndombe asked Verner to remain as his friend, to teach is people. After an exchange of gifts, Verner was provided with food and a place to set up his camp.

Situated on the Lubi River which flows into the Kasai at Wissmann Falls, about three hours’ walk away, Ndombe’s town was the focal point of six roads that led there from the surrounding regions. It consisted of a cluster of separate villages, with the King’s village at its center. The houses of the latter were arranged along streets and narrow lanes, and the houses of the King’s wives, numbering over thirty, occupied the center of the village. After visiting the various parts of the town with the King as his guide, Verner selected a site for a more permanent camp in an abandoned manioc field and purchased it from its owner. In the following days visitors from surrounding areas arrived, especially from the Bena Mfula (probably a Luluwa subdivision) who lived south of Ndombe, bringing goods to exchange with the newcomer. After the novelty of having a White man living among them wore off, Verner dealt mainly with the inhabitants of Ndombe’s town. He bargained especially with Djoka, Ndombe’s prime minister, an enterprising businessman whose operations extended over two-hundred miles of territory and included trade in rubber, ivory, bloodwood (mukulu, pterocarpus angolensis), and copper. With such a commercially-minded people, it is not surprising that Verner was able to trade for ritual and symbolic objects as well as for the necessities of life. “If they love their idols,” writes Verner, “they do not love them nearly so much as they do the idol that their more civilized cousins worship — money — in whatever form.” [Verner, 1903, p. 312.]

Verner relates a bit of the traditional history of the origin of the Bikenge as told him by Ndombe and others. It pertains to their separation from the principal branch of the Kuba, the branch led by the Lukengu or King of the Bushongo Kuba. After a former Lukengu had tried to sacrifice slaves belonging to the Bikenge aristocracy (Bakwampesh), there was a fight and the latter, with their followers, withdrew to the south of the Lulua, outside the area controlled by the Lukengu, and set up their own capital near Wissmann Falls on the upper Kasai River. The recent head of this group had been Mai Mukesi; but when officers of the Congo government visited the region some years before Verner’s arrival, Mai Mukesi had fled in fear. Ndombe, however, remained, befriended the Whites, and his claim to the chieftainship was supported by the regional administrator. Ndombe’s mother’s brother, Mai Munene, had been King of the Bikenge, and though Ndombe’s father had come from the Bashilele country and was thus probably of the Lele tribe, the right of a nephew to succeed to his mother’s brother’s position was traditional among many of the peoples of the area. Ndombe now controlled a large area inhabited by people of several ethnic groups including, besides his own Bikenge branch of the Kuba nation, people of Luba, Biombo, Lele, Pende, and Mfula or Luluwa origin, and also some villages of Pygmies. His subjects numbered about 100,000 according to Verner’s estimate [Verner, 1903, pp. 184-86; see also the manuscript The Travels of Ntoka, pp. 5, 94-5; and Verner, 1899b].

In May of 1897 Verner went back to Luebo to open negotiations for the founding of a mission at Ndombe’s. he quickly received the local administrator’s verbal approval to reside at Ndombe’s, and made formal application to the government for a grant of land there for a mission station, a matter that he was told would normally take about a year to process.

Upon his return to Ndombe’s, Verner was greeted by Belinge, the King’s cousin, who persuaded Verner to visit his town some twenty miles distant. Belinge’s people were also of the Kuba nation; but there were among them also people of the Pende group who lived to the west, including a Pende smith who, as was considered befitting a man of knowledge of the mysteries of metallurgy, says Verner, always remained silent while others conversed. The missionary, attracted to the man, made him a present of some large brass wire, and in return, the smith made a fine small dagger for Verner “… with a shining keen blade and a carved wooden handle, covered at the hilt with beaten copper” (apparently not in the Smithsonian). Verner also acquired the four-chambered bellows used by the smith in producing drafts for his smithy (which is in the Smithsonian). [Verner, 1903, p. 203.]

On July 4 of 1897 Verner commenced a trip down the Kasai from the foot of Wissmann Falls to its confluence with the Lulua, accompanied by twenty men, women, and boys of the region, in two dugout canoes. On the right bank lived the friendly Kuba, Kete, and Biombo people; on the left the Lele, some of whom were considered treacherous enemies and especially resistant to the Free State government. Verner’s canoe took the lead and reached its destination safely, but the second canoe never arrived. All aboard, except for one man who escaped to tell the story, had been attacked and killed or carried off by the Luidi, a faction of the Lele who had been at war with the Whites for many years, and who mistook Verner and his party for government agents. Later Verner learned that he had unwittingly gotten into the place where the Lele ferried slaves across the Kasai, and they apparently feared that the discovery would put an end to their trade [Verner, August 1899, p. 377].

When he returned to Ndombe’s capital, the King repeatedly assured Verner that his people were not responsible for the attack and urged the missionary to remain with them as a teacher. Verner had a simple house built, the work being done under the direction of the King’s son, and there he resided for the following year. Made in the African manner, it was constructed basically of palm leaf stems and walled with palm leaves, all tied together with raffia palm fiber; the steep roof was heavily thatched with grass. Ensconced in his new residence, Verner spent his days instructing Ndombe’s people in Christian legends and beliefs and his evenings entertaining them with magic-lantern shows of religious pictures and with a mechanical music box.

King Ndombe played the role of chief judge among his people, and Verner describes his activities in settling a dispute that had broken out between the Kete and Kuba inhabitants of the place. After pacifying the opposing parties, Ndombe set the date for a trial, which took place about two weeks later. Ndombe was seated upon a carved seat, which Verner calls the “throne” as it had been inherited from the earlier chiefs of the kingdom. The King, formally dressed, wore a beautifully embroidered cap, ornamented with beads and eagle feathers. His legs were decorated with many fine bracelets and anklets, and the embroidered cloth around his waist was bedecked with beads and cowries. The throne was placed upon a leopard skin, befitting a ruler, and the King’s long spear and symbol of his authority was stuck, blade up, in the ground beside him. The men attending the hearing were required to leave their weapons behind, but many brought their sewing, for, as elsewhere among the peoples of this region, the men did the needlework. After hearing the cases presented by lawyers for the opposing sides, King Ndombe imposed penalties on both of the men who had started the affair, one being obliged to serve the Chief as a servant until redeemed by his relatives, and the other being obliged to pay a fine of 5000 cowries to the King [Verner, 1903, pp. 237-43; and August 18 Papers, 1897].

Among the inhabitants of Ndombe’s realm were bands of BaTwa (Pygmies), some of whom made their home on the outskirts of Ndombe’s capital town. They lived by hunting and fishing and sold the surplus meat they obtained to the other people in exchange for cultivated foodstuffs or other goods. Verner traded for their meat with salt which they craved. He declares that they practiced none of the advanced crafts that the other Bantu-speaking people of the area were expert at and lived a very simple life, keeping mainly to themselves and not intermarrying with the larger people of the region.

On at least two occasions, in the years 1897-98, Verner traveled into BaKete country on a visit to a newly opened mission station at Ibanj (Ibange) north of the Lulua River. The inhabitants of the villages in this region were subjects of the Kuba King, the Lukengu of Bushongo. At Ibanj there was a regional market where traders from about a dozen towns gathered every sixth day to barter their wares. Besides foodstuffs, the merchants offered clay pots, ornaments, pieces of raffia cloth and specimens of embroidery and art work. Mukulu (the red wood that Verner erroneously calls “camwood”), copper crosses, and native rubber were also to be found, some being acquired by itinerant traders for export; also salt from Luanda and imported goods from Europe were offered for sale, especially cloth, beads, and knives. Slaves were still sold there, says Verner, in demand not only for labor but as food for cannibalistic peoples living north of the Sankuru. Though he gives no detail, it was doubtless on trips such as this that Verner acquired objects from the Kete and Kuba of the region to the east of Luebo. He is a little more revealing in his discussion of blacksmithing, noting that every village had from one to three smiths, and that each of these had several apprentices. “I frequently had my work done by them,” says Verner, “and their skill amazed me. They had the art of tempering copper as well as of making steel soft. Some of the objects of their craft, which I placed in the National Museum at Washington, are revelations to the uninitiated in their remarkable complexity and variety.” [Verner, 1903, p. 294; figure 00.]

The weaving of fine raffia cloth, Verner observes, is considered a “high art,” and,

… the principal men and women take great delight in it… The sewing and fine embroidery work… is done entirely by the men, except that the Kings’ wives are sometimes privileged to do some fancy work. A woman is rarely seen with a needle and a man never with a hoe… the men may be seen about the streets with their sewing in their hands and they carry their work of this sort into court with them… The needles, of copper and iron, are made by their own blacksmiths and I used them quite often in my own work. The coarser ones resemble a bodkin, except that the points are sharper. [Verner, 1903, pp. 295-97.]

Verner also admired the skill displayed in wood and ivory carving. “They can produce a geometrical figure whose perfection is amazing. Their tools are of the simplest, yet they carve figures of men and animals, pipes, bowls, cups, platters, tables and fantastic images.” The rubbing oracle, usually in the form of a bush pig, called “lubuki,” meaning “that which causes to know or reveals,” says Verner, is used most often to detect thieves or to reveal secrets [Verner, 1903, pp. 293 and 312; see figure 00].

Verner spent part of his time exploring the country roundabout Ndombe, and on December 15 of 1897 he fell into a disguised pit prepared for trapping animals. A poisoned stake placed pointing upwards in the bottom of the put cut a two-inch gouge in his right thigh. His Black companion, Kassongo (a local freed slave whom Verner later brought to the U.S. to be educated), ran to the nearest village for help and some time later men arrived to carry Verner to Bindundu, a BaKete village. Two hours in the hot sun and infection with a powerful poison had nearly finished him. A Zapo-Zap woman skilled in practical remedies instructed Kassongo to suck out as much of the poisoned blood as possible. A hot cassava poultice was then applied, and Verner made use of some of the medical supplies he had brought with him. He lay in Bindundu for two weeks, often delirious, until men could carry him to Ndombe where his missionary companions, Phipps and Hawkins, tended him. Finally the wound began to heal, but it gave him trouble from time to time, and later Verner spent almost a year in a Baltimore hospital because of complications growing out of this accident.

When a troop of about fifty Congolese soldiers, mostly of the Luba tribe, making the annual round to collect the tribute in ivory and rubber demanded by the Congo government, arrived at Ndombe’s headquarters, Verner’s ingenuity was taxed to prevent hostilities from breaking out. The people of Ndombe’s region had only recently come under the control of the government and were not at all pleased with the demands for tribute and the requirement that they provide food for the soldiers. On the one hand Verner tried to persuade Ndombe’s and his people that taxation was necessary for the advancement of the country, and on the other hand he tried to impress upon the soldiers and their leader (a sergeant of the Tetela tribe) that they should conduct themselves in a peaceful manner. After defusing some touchy situations on the first day, Verner the next day invited the soldiers to attend a magic-lantern show — probably mostly of Bible story scenes — which he explicated in the Luba language, and followed that by singing some American songs translated into Luba. He must also have preached to them on the evils of superstition, for the next day he writes, “I was agreeably surprised at the decision they announced to resume their march at once. They brought me their idols, charms, amulets, and fetishes to exchange for some beautiful cards [probably lithographed religious scenes] friends had sent me from America, and each one wrapped his picture up with the utmost care and bade me a cordial farewell.” Then, he continues, “I saw bands of armed natives [Ndombe’s men] issue from the surrounding woods after the soldiers had departed, and I estimated that there must have been over 5000 in all.” [Verner, 1903, p. 376]

At certain times during this first visit to Central Africa, Verner made exploratory trips on behalf of the Congo Railway Company. Details of these journeys have not been found, neither in his published writings nor in the papers that are archived under his name at the South Caroliniana Library. However, in a brief autobiographical sketch prepared many years later, Verner wrote:

Having had education and some experience in engineering and in railway service, I was asked by the officials of the Congo Railway, since I was to be in that region anyhow for quite a while, to join with them in a preliminary survey of a part of the railroad, which I did, at the same time consolidating and arranging the business of the transport for the industrial mission on a firm basis. Without going into all the details of this first expedition, I say briefly that I explored practically the whole of the Kasai Valley, a large region in Portuguese Angola, a considerable territory on the southern bank of the main stream of the Congo, acquired one native tongue very fluently, four others sufficiently for practical purposes, exercised my French to the point of business practicability, and made a complete and thorough study of the scientific and commercial possibilities of the country, as well as those conditions bearing upon my immediate work. [Autobiography, p. 3.]

Verner’s vision of opening a new mission at Ndombe was not to be fulfilled, both because of opposition from the Executive Committee of the Foreign Missions of the Presbyterian Church in the United States and of delay on the part of the Congo government to grant a concession of land. While still at Ndombe and recovering from the wound he suffered when he fell into the game pit, Verner received a letter from the Foreign Mission Committee of his Church chiding him for the “spirit of insubordination” expressed in his letters and for attempting to open a new mission station without either conference with, or permission from, the Committee. This had been offset, in Verner’s mind at least, by his receipt of a “substantial contribution” from a minister friend and his Church of the Strangers in New York, “for the prosecution of the cause.” In a June 1898 letter from the Secretary of the mission Committee, Verner was ordered to return home at once, because of the reports of his impaired health.

At about the same time, Verner received a communication from the Chef de Poste at Luluabourg asking him to vacate the place he occupied at Ndombe. The reason, Verner surmises, was the outbreak of hostilities between the government and some Lulua people not far away and also the plans being made by the administration to mount a campaign against the Lukengu of Bushongo.

While Verner made arrangements to depart from Ndombe, the King paid him numerous visits to talk with him about his teachings and to get his explanations of current events. “With him came great crowds of his people, and as the news spread, of the inhabitants of other towns and villages, all imploring me to stay with them. They brought many presents of food and fine specimens of their art and handicraft, as farewell tokens of their esteem, which formed quite a large and varied collection.” [Verner, 1903, p. 396.]

Verner had shown Ndombe pictures of President McKinley and had told him of the war with Spain that America was engaged in at the time, news of which reached the missionaries in American magazines. In a touching gesture of good will, Ndombe dictated a message to President McKinley, asking him to send out “men who have good hearts to help the Black people, to teach them, to keep the peace with them, and to be their friends.” Along with the message Ndombe sent a large new robe and his big ivory trumpet as gifts for the President. (These items were not included in the collection that came to the Smithsonian and they do not appear to be present in any of the public collections of memorabilia of President McKinley.)

Though his predecessors at Luebo had concentrated their linguistic efforts on learning the Kuba language, Verner had early decided that Tshiluba, the language spoken by the Luba and Bena Lulua peoples, was the most important in the area — it was spoken by the greatest number of the local people and a majority of the converts at the mission. All the slaves in the area were Luba, and the Luba linguistic area was the largest in the entire Congo region. While waiting for a river steamer to come up to Luebo, Verner recorded that he completed work on a dictionary of 1000 Luba words and made a start at analyzing the grammar. (These linguistic works have not been located.) He taught some Luba-speaking people to read and stimulated their interest in acquiring an education. During this period he continued to collect examples of local handicrafts. “A Zapo-Zap carpenter made me a beautiful chair, using nothing but his knife. Another Zapo-Zap, learning that some of my boys wished to go to America, brought some beautiful battle-axes to help defray the expenses.” [Verner, 1903, p. 403; figure 00.]

Verner brought two young men of the Tetela tribe, who had been slaves of the Luba, home to America with him to send them to school. One, Kassongo who had saved his life when he fell into the elephant trap, died in a stampede in Birmingham, Alabama, in 1902 following an address by Booker T. Washington; and the other, Kondola, after several years in the U.S., eventually returned to the Kasai. Verner also carried with him, from the interior of the Congo, a collection of ethnological, mineralogical, and zoological specimens. In addition, he had two monkeys, a wild cat, and some chameleons, all brought out alive and destined for the New York Zoological Gardens in Central Park.

Verner had not given up his dream of a concession of land at Ndombe and when he arrived in Belgium, he was assured that upon his return to the Congo the way would be fully open for him to occupy a site at Ndombe. From Verner’s discussion of the developmental possibilities of the Congo in the last few chapters of his book, Pioneering in Central Africa, it is clear that he hoped to be able to establish a rubber, ivory, and palm-oil collecting station at Ndombe, and to use it as a base to explore for and develop the mineral and timber wealth of the region. In short, he dreamed of returning to participate in the development of the Congo with American financial backing.

On his return trip to Europe from Africa, Verner busied himself with writing articles about his experiences and some of these were published in newspapers in England. An article on the Pygmies, published in the Spectator, secured for him an audience among scientific men and societies. In England he also arranged to have a small religious book published in the Luba language, the first such ever to be printed. But with this act, his activities as a missionary essentially came to an end and Verner resigned his position as a missionary shortly after arriving home in 1899.

A day or two after arriving in New York (where Verner had some difficulty in looking after his African companions — they were callously turned out of the rooming house where he thought he had procured their lodging and had gotten lost for some hours in the streets of New York City on a cold February night), he proceeded with his collection and his wards to Washington and to the Smithsonian Institution. He had written to the Institution not long after reaching Luebo some three years earlier, offering to collect flora and fauna from the Kasai region and asking for lists of whatever was needed to complete the Institution’s holdings from that part of the world. Curators in the departments of Anthropology and Zoology had responded and now when Verner arrived with his collections, he was not wholly unexpected. Accepting the hospitality of his uncle, the Honorable Samuel Phillips, he was able to remain in Washington in order to provide information on the materials he had brought. In September of 1899, again in Washington, Verner offered to “place one specimen of each article” in the Smithsonian, apparently intending to retain the remainder of what he indicates was a very sizable collection (occupying about 1000 cubic feet of space) either for his own purposes or for disposal elsewhere. Agreement was reached with the Institution that he would receive $200 for the selected lot of specimens on condition that he prepare a catalog to accompany it. However, such a catalog has not been found in the Smithsonian’s files. Rather, there are some scanty notes on certain items filed among the papers of the Curator, Walter Hough, apparently based upon information dictated by Verner. In November of 1899 Verner wrote to the Secretary of the Institution that he had “named and described the articles” and that he was preparing monographs on certain industries which they illustrate, and submitted one as an example. These were to deal with rubber collecting, textile manufacture, copper mining and manufacture, and pottery. On this basis, Verner was sent the payment promised. Unfortunately, the descriptive articles are not to be found in the Smithsonian’s files.

Verner at one time wrote to Smithsonian Secretary, S. P. Langley, that “I have also in this country two boys of the BaTetela tribe of the Bantu race whom I should like the Institution to make models of. They could be used to illustrate photographically some of the arts and industries of their people.” Apparently this offer was not taken up, as no records of models or photographs of the BaTetela men have been found in the Smithsonian’s anthropological records. However, the association that Verner made with certain Smithsonian scientists was an enduring one, for he corresponded with them over the next twenty years. Verner states in a short autobiography that one result of his relations with the Smithsonian Institution was the fostering of interest in African matters, principally scientific, on the part of many influential American scientists.

After spending some months in a Baltimore hospital because the injury suffered to his leg in the fall into an animal trap had not properly healed, Verner returned to the Stillman Institute in Alabama where he was employed as Superintendent of the Industrial Division. He writes that the money he received for the collection sold to the Smithsonian made it possible for him to marry. During this period he published some articles about Africa in popular magazines and newspapers and lectured on Africa to church groups. In 1903 he wrote to the Smithsonian requesting a loan of some of the ethnographic objects that he had sold to it in order to illustrate lectures he was giving to raise funds for a return trip to Africa, explaining that the collections he had retained had been lost in a fire. Correspondence in the Smithsonian’s files show that the request was granted.

Verner the Anthropologist

A great exposition was being planned in St. Louis to celebrate the one-hundredth anniversary of the Louisiana Purchase. Those in charge had engaged W. J. McGee, a former Smithsonian ethnologist, to head a Department of Anthropology and Ethnology, and McGee and his associates conceived the idea of exhibiting exotic peoples, both from the United States and from far off places. African Pygmies were included among the ethnic types they hoped to bring to the Fair where the groups would display their various modes of life. When Verner learned of the proposed exhibits he at once wrote to McGee offering to bring a group of Central African Pygmies to the Exposition, and rashly suggested that he could do it for no more than $1000. McGee expressed interest in the proposal (though, he said, he really had in mind the Akko Pygmies from deeper in the interior of the Congo whom he thought would be less affected by other cultures). But McGee at the same time was skeptical of Verner’s very low estimate of the cost which would have to include two trips to the Congo, one to fetch the Pygmies, and an interpreter for them, and a second to return them to their homes. When Verner was able to travel to St. Louis to meet McGee, they arrived at a more realistic estimate of the cost. McGee budgeted $8500 to cover the two trips and a salary for Verner. He also wisely set aside an extra $1500 for unforeseen contingencies and in the end even this proved too little. Verner was to attempt to bring back not only a dozen BaTwa or Cwa Pygmies, four “red people,” and two “black people” for the Fair, but also a collection of artifacts to illustrate the ways of life of all these peoples, photographs of villages and of individuals engaged in various activities, and detailed ethnographic information covering a broad range of subjects. In October of 1903 Verner was commissioned a Special Agent of the Anthropology Department of the Exposition and soon thereafter left on his new mission to Africa, provided with official letters of recommendation signed by McGee as President of the newly formed American Anthropological Association and as Acting President of the National Geographic Society.

McGee’s acceptance of Verner’s proposal was due in large part to the fact that Verner had already established himself as an authority on Central Africa. He had written several articles on the region, and especially on the BaTwa Pygmies, that had appeared in popular journals and newspapers; and just at this time his book, Pioneering in Central Africa, was being published. A kind of journal of his experiences as a missionary among the Luba, Kuba, and neighboring peoples, the work provided interesting details on African life in the Luebo region of the Kasai District. Verner also had ready an article, entitled “The Yellow Men of Africa,” which was accepted for publication in the American Anthropologist, dealing with what Verner considered to be a distinct segment of the population of Central and Southern Africa: copper-colored in hue, taller than the majority of the Blacks, and with aquiline noses. Verner took his friend, King Ndombe, to be an example of this “superior” type which he judged was the result of mixture with people moving south from North Africa in ancient times. (He hoped to be able to persuade King Ndombe to come to St. Louis as a representative of these “red” or “yellow” people, but was unsuccessful.)

In Brussels in December of 1903, Verner was promised cooperation and assistance (free use of the state steamer) by the Congo government. By the end of March, 1904, he had made his way back to Ndombe’s village where he was warmly greeted by his old friend and where he explained his reason for coming. Persuading the Pygmies to accompany him from their home in the Kasai forest to the unknown country across the great sea was no simple feat:

To overcome the natural shyness of the little BaTwa, so that the matter could be discussed at all; to give them any adequate idea of the great gathering to which they were invited; to overcome their fear of the journey; to convince them of the good faith of the dreaded White man; to placate their kinspeople and friends; to combat the ignorance and prejudice of thousands of years — this was surely a task not to be despised. Then, too, above all things, the African loves deliberation. The great haste needed in this expedition vastly increased its intrinsic difficulties. This was a matter, in the minds of the natives, for many month’s consultation and consideration. Yet I had to ask them to leave in three weeks’ time. The very proposition sounded absurd. [Verner, 1904, p. 1619.]

The BaTwa Pygmy men were worried about their families’ safety in a time of frequent hostilities and were only persuaded with the help of Ota Benga, a Pygmy of another group who had already attached himself to Verner, and by some of Ndombe’s councilors, as well as with bribes of salt and guns.

In April of 1904 Verner, while still at Ndombe’s village, wrote to McGee about the problems he was having. Hostilities had broken out between the Lele and the government and some of the Lele came under Ndombe’s chieftainship. Also, there was trouble over the demands for taxes being made by the Congo government. To encourage the production of copper in Katanga, the government had decreed that the tribute was to be paid only in copper crosses of the type produced in Katanga. But the government wanted also to encourage the gathering of wild rubber and so refused to sell the copper crosses to the people in Kasai except in exchange for rubber. The Lukengu, King of the Bushongo, had been jailed for not paying sufficient tribute and now Ndombe, who had recently paid a tax, was being pressed for the payment of still more and was summoned to the administrative post in Luebo where he feared he also would be imprisoned. He consulted with his old friend, Verner, who advised him it would be best to comply. However, Ndombe’s people were not so easily persuaded. They had shot off their guns, made fresh poison for their arrows, and were preparing for war. Verner judged it might not be possible to persuade any of Ndombe’s people to accompany him under the circumstances. In a few weeks, however, the tension eased and Verner, with those who finally agreed to accompany him, walked to Djoka Punda where they caught a river steamer for the trip down the Kasai River to Leopoldville. Some twenty men had indicated a desire to accompany Verner to America but when the time for departure came, only nine were willing to go and of those, only four were BaTwa, the others being two Kuba youths, Kondola (Verner’s Tetela companion from the first trip whom Verner had brought with him to America in 1899 and whose return to Africa with Verner helped to persuade the Pygmies that it was safe to accompany the White man to his country), a Luba man, and Ota Benga, whose story is told below. The newly completed railroad carried them to the mouth of the Congo where they found a steamer for New Orleans. Six weeks after leaving their home in the Kasai, the Congolese were in America. But Verner, who suffered an attack of fever, was carried on a stretcher into a New Orleans hospital and someone had to be sent from St. Louis to conduct the Congolese there with Kondola serving as their interpreter and spokesman.

It would not be fair to say that those in charge of the anthropological exhibits at the St. Louis Exposition had any desire to show off the Pygmies and other peoples from distant lands as though they were freaks. Verner writes:

It was understood that [the Pygmies] were to come voluntarily if at all, and we were to take good care of them. They were not to be exhibited in dime museums or on the Pike or in any other way than under the most respectable scientific auspices; a condition which was entirely carried out. This was the first time that any of these people had ever left Africa, although every explorer from Du Ghaillu to Stanley had tried to get some out. [Autobiography, pp. 5-6.]

In recognition of his success, Verner was awarded the Grand Prize by the International Jury of the St. Louis Exposition and John Kondola, the Tetela man, received a bronze medal (American Anthropologist, 1905, n.s. 7, p. 157). Reports of the anthropological parts of the exposition stress especially the living exhibits, where representatives of some thirty tribal peoples lived in houses of their own construction. The Pygmies along with the other exotic peoples became subjects for anthropometric and photographic studies in a Laboratory of Anthropometry set up at the exposition (Starr, 1905). There is, however, no mention of the African artifacts that Verner had agreed to bring.

While in St. Louis in connection with the exhibit at the Exposition, Verner came to know several people who were influential in his later career. Finding lodging next door to the McGees, he got to know W. J. McGee as a friend as well as a sponsor. When the time came for the BaTwa Pygmies to be returned to their homes in Africa, McGee strongly supported Verner’s application for the assignment above those of rivals who wanted the opportunity of a trip to the Congo. Members of the Putnam family of Davenport, Iowa, invited Verner and one of the BaTwa Pygmies to visit them, and Verner, accompanied by his little friend from the Congo, appeared at the Davenport Academy of Sciences where Verner lectured. The Putnams arranged for Verner to make an ethnographic collection for the Academy of Sciences on his next trip to Africa. And the Director of the Missouri Botanical Gardens commissioned Verner to make a collection of living plants from the southern Congo for the Gardens, a contract that Verner carried out with great success. He was offered $5000 a week to exhibit the Pygmies in Madison Square Garden for several weeks and $4000 a week to exhibit them in London; but he turned down both offers.

At the St. Louis Exposition there were several professional anthropologists who had also been engaged to bring groups of exotic peoples to the Fair, especially George A. Dorsey who brought several delegations from several American Indian tribes, and Professor Frederick Starr of the University of Chicago who brought a group of Ainu from northern Japan. In conjunction with the exhibits, Professor Starr conducted a field school in anthropology and ethnology with lectures and class work, using individuals from the various aboriginal groups as informants (Bennitt and Stockbridge, 1905, p. 678 f). Though information on Verner’s activities at St. Louis is scanty, he may well have participated in some of these exercises, and he surely had ample opportunity to get to know Starr and the other anthropologists.

Verner reports little about the Pygmies’ experiences in America, except to say that they were shocked to see White men and women dancing together. Upon returning home they described this form of dancing, and the old men asserted that they would not stand for any such heathenish practices among their people. Verner describes a Congo dance in which men and women are arranged on opposite sides of a circle and dance toward each other, advancing and retiring alternately; occasionally a man jumps into the circle and whirls about. He continues in a philosophical vein:

I have sometimes thought that the physical frenzy into which some of the American Colored people used to fall on religious revival occasions may have had its roots in the hereditary influence of those African dances, since there is a primitive religious idea associated with them. Professor Starr said that it was the phallic idea which underlies so many primitive religions. I am not sure about that myself, but the professor was a very learned man. [Reference?]

Having brought back not only artifacts and information but real people from Central Africa, and having contributed both popular and scholarly articles on the peoples and customs of Africa, Verner, although not educated in anthropology, began to think of himself as an anthropologist and was apparently accepted as such by others in the developing discipline. Though his name is not among those who were invited by McGee and others in 1903 to join together for the purpose of organizing a national anthropological society, he is listed in 1905 as a founding member of the American Anthropological Association [American Anthropologist, 7, 1905, p. 182].

Returning the Congolese

and Exploring for Specimens

When the weather turned cold in St. Louis, Verner and his African charges began the long journey back to the Congo. But in New Orleans one after another of the Blacks came down with chicken pox and their departure was prevented by the authorities. In Havana there was a further delay while waiting for the boat which would take them home and Verner had to appeal repeatedly to McGee for additional funds. Finally reaching Leopoldville, the Congolese were paid for their services in cash which they spent for goods to take home to their families and Verner duly conducted them back to Ndombe’s country.

Verner then set about making a collection of plants for the Missouri Botanical Gardens, exploring for wild rubber, looking for minerals, and supporting himself in part by selling rubber and ivory to the trading posts. Also, he had a contract to make photographs for Underwood and Underwood, the American firm that sold stereopticon views and news photos. Through this entire trip, which stretched on for about a year and a half, he continued to collect ethnographic objects for sale to museums in the United States. In the process, he greatly extended his knowledge of the lower Kasai and penetrated Kuba country more deeply than before. He later wrote that he had made himself expert in the anthropology of the region.

Professor Starr, a physical anthropologist and ethnologist, had studied the peoples of Mexico and Japan and, after coming into contact with Verner’s Pygmies and other Congolese, developed a desire to extend his knowledge of other lands and peoples to Africa [Starr, 1912, p. 7]. Verner was, of course, committed to returning his African charges to their homes in the Kasai region and it is not unlikely that they discussed a joint expedition. At any rate, Starr accepted Verner’s invitation to visit him in Ndombe’s country, but did not depart for Africa until more than a year after Verner had left on his third trip. In recognition of his effort in taking Congolese to the United States and returning them to their homes, King Leopold II, with Ndombe’s approval, had given Verner a tract of land in the Kasai region for the installation of an institute of technology and scientific research. The place was, of course, located in the domain of Verner’s old friend, King Ndombe. Upon his return to the Congo, Verner made his headquarters there and had some buildings constructed. He announced that his purposes were to introduce arts and industries to the people of the region, to train them, and to investigate scientific questions presented by the new country; also, he hoped to establish a hospital. All this was to be supported by developing the commercial potential of the area. Verner called the place ceded over to him “Mt. Washington,” and that became his headquarters for the collecting activities. It was there, to Verner’s camp, that Professor Starr went to make a study of the local BaTwa. But soon after arriving, Starr suffered a sever attack of malaria and had to be nursed through it by Verner. Because of his slow recovery, the Professor was unable to pursue the extensive ethnological collecting that he had planned to undertake. Verner was willing to carry out the task for him; and so Starr engaged Verner to travel about collecting artifacts while the former busied himself with studies of the people settled near Ndombe.

Verner set out on a dangerous circuit through the countries of hostile tribes that were not yet under the control of the central government — the Lele, Ndundu, Mpenda, and Luba of the Kasai. Some seven years earlier Verner had lost seven men while skirting Lele country, and now the Lele feared he had returned to punish them. This time, however, through a combination of astute bravado, demonstrations of White man’s magic, and sheer luck, Verner managed to complete a peaceful circuit, purchasing examples of arts and crafts from each of the peoples he visited and also capturing dangerous horned vipers alive for American zoos. He returned by canoe down the Upper Kasai, a river-running feat that, from his description of it, rivals the thrills of the Colorado. Verner claimed to be the first White man to travel through these countries. Certainly he is one of the first to make extensive ethnographic collections of Pende and Lele materials, though Frobenius collected along the borders of Pende country earlier in the same year [see below].

Starr, during Verner’s absence, had inquired of King Ndombe to be shown the ceremony by which subjects paid homage to their chief. Perhaps not wholly understanding the request and lacking a good interpreter, Ndombe had proceeded to demonstrate the ritual by kneeling at Starr’s feet and performing gestures of obeisance. At this, some of his subjects concluded that he had indeed recognized Starr as his superior, and Ndombe found himself in danger of losing his kingdom to the rival that he had replaced. Ndombe summoned a councilor from Lukengu’s court who advised him to move his capital to a new site so that he would not be obliged to recognize Starr’s sovereignty, if the latter should choose to exercise it, on the logic that it would pertain only to the chief who lived at the old capital. This turn of events left Starr, still recuperating at Verner’s camp, completely perplexed. Only when Verner returned and got the story from Ndombe himself was the mystery cleared up.

In the course of his stay at Verner’s camp, Starr engaged in a study of the BaTwa language and collected folk tales. He concluded that some of the words that other investigators of the Pygmies — Pogge and Wolfe — had recorded among Pygmies on the Uele River, some 1000 miles to the north, were also present in the language of the BaTwa Pygmies of the Kasai.

Verner writes that when Professor Starr found how well the collections that had been made for him suited his requirements, he expressed a wish for still more, from other peoples in the vicinity. Verner then suggested making a trip to the home of the Lukengu, King of the Bushongo Kuba, and Starr decided to extend his period in the Kasai District in order to acquire museum specimens from that region. Unfortunately, Verner’s publications and his papers preserved at the South Caroliniana Library do not include a detailed description of that trip. He wrote later that he went “… overland to the BaKuba Kingdom and brought back splendid specimens for the Professor… His collections are now chiefly in the American Museum of Natural History, New York.” [Verner, The Travels of Ntoka, p. 100.]

From his letters to his wife, it appears that Verner did not intend that his third trip to the Congo would be so long. In January of 1905 he wrote that he hoped to catch one of the next two river steamers that would come up the Kasai; but in November of 1905 he was still in the Congo and his wife wrote to McGee that her husband was practically stranded for lack of funds. McGee sent him a letter of credit for $500. By that time McGee had become Director of the Saint Louis Public Museum and Verner had written to him offering to sell the museum a collection of Congo materials. McGee replied, saying: “… it is probable that we should be able to take from you on your arrival a limited number of typical objects representing native industries and customs in Africa.” (But the records of the St. Louis Museum of Art, successor to the Saint Louis Public Museum, I am told, do not show the accession of a collection made by S. P. Verner.)

After Starr’s departure, Verner packed his own collections which included two ntokas (horned vipers) and a chimpanzee with whom he thought to make friends of the New York Zoological Gardens.

Apparently coming out of this third trip to Central Africa was a series of adventure stories that Verner tentatively entitled: “How we tamed Bashilele.” The Lele were considered by the Whites to be a notoriously hostile tribe in the area at that time. (The articles apparently were published in the Brevard News, a newspaper published in the town in North Carolina where Verner lived for a while after returning from his third African trip. A partial manuscript of the work was made available to me by one of Verner’s descendants.) In one of these articles Verner claims that no other White man had gone into the interior on the west bank of the Kasai River, below the point where Livingstone had crossed it fifty years before, and that Livingstone himself had not reached the Lele country. Verner describes and comments upon the preparation and use of lulenga poison, made from a vine and used by Pygmies on their arrows, and also upon the use of raffia palm leaves for thatching and other structural purposes. But these ethnographic details are presented mainly to embellish the adventure stories.

Verner spent a considerable part of his third trip to the Congo studying the business of collecting wild rubber, especially the kind derived from the landolphia vine, and experimenting with practices that might improve the yield in the exploitation of this natural resource. He became more and more convinced that, with adequate American capital and good management, he could convert a lackadaisical business into a thriving and highly profitable industry.

In mid-1906 Verner finally left the Congo to return to America, and although records from this third trip are few, there is a receipt, dated 23 June 1906 and issued in Sierra Leone, acknowledging the payment of £35 for one chimpanzee. Arriving in England, Verner wrote from a Liverpool hotel to a shipping and travel agent on 17 July 1906 seeking passage to America for himself and one African Pygmy as well as transportation for fifty cases of specimens which he briefly describes as “… valuable orchids and ethnographic materials besides two very valuable chimpanzees.”

The Pygmy, named “Ota Benga,” had been captured in war by the Lele tribe and found in their hands by soldiers in the service of the Congo State who freed him from his captors and brought him to a military post on the Kasai, thus saving him from becoming the pièce de résistance of a cannibal feast, the usual fate of captives taken by the Lele, according to Verner.

The tales that Verner related, either in interviews with newspaper reporters or in articles he himself wrote, concerning his discovery of Ota Benga, are peculiarly variable in the description of the circumstances surrounding their first meeting; and unless all are somehow true though incomplete, they cannot fail to raise questions concerning the amount of fiction in Verner’s African adventure stories. According to an item published in the St. Louis Post-Despatch (September 4, 1904), and also an article penned by Verner for Harper’s Weekly (October 22, 1904), Ota Benga was being held captive by the Bashilele and Verner redeemed him for five dollars’ worth of trade goods. A somewhat less mercenary story was published by the (South Carolina) Columbus Dispatch (September 11, 1904) which has it that Verner found Ota Benga with a few other members of his tribe at a place only a few miles from their settlement and that, by arrangement with one of the chiefs, Ota Benga was allowed to accompany Verner. The claim that he himself redeemed the Pygmy seems to be wholly contradicted in a story by Verner himself entitled “Canning the Crocodile,” in which he writes that

Ota Benga had been captured in war by enemies of his tribe and had been found in their hands when they in turn had been defeated in a battle by troops of the Congo government. The surviving members of the tribe having meanwhile gone very far away, Ota Benga, when released by the soldiers, had chosen to live with them for his own safety until be heard… that I wanted to employ Pygmies.

Ota Benga, Verner says, was of the Chirichiri or Badi (Badzing?) group and his language differed from that of the BaTwa of King Ndombe’s region with which Verner was familiar. Because of his small stature, Verner considered him a Pygmy. He was a member of the group of Congolese that Verner took to St. Louis in 1903 and had returned with them to the Congo in 1905. Verner writes that he attempted to restore Ota Benga to his people but that they had moved far away because of warfare in the region. Then he asked the BaTwa living near Ndombe’s town to take the stranger. They accepted Ota Benga and gave him a wife, but a snake bit the wife; she died and the BaTwa attributed the event to the stranger’s witchcraft and would have no more to do with him. When Verner prepared to leave, he says, Ota Benga insisted upon going back to America with him and he was afraid to abandon the Pygmy for fear he would again fall into slavery. A present of some ivory from an African chief provided the expenses of Ota Benga’s second trip to America.

Having arrived in New York, Verner deposited some ethnographic specimens at the American Museum of Natural History, as well as the Pygmy and the two chimpanzees, while he made a quick trip to his home in Brevard, North Carolina. Dr. H. C. Bumpus, Director of the Museum, wrote to him there advising him that he should dispose of the ethnographic collection he had brought in such manner “as will be of greatest advantage to you,” a statement that implies that Verner wished to sell the specimens and that the American Museum was unable to take them. The Chimpanzees, he was told, should be offered to the Zoological Park. “I have bought a duck suit for the Pygmy,” the letter continues. “He is around the Museum, apparently perfectly happy, and more or less a favorite of the men. How long we can keep his identity away from the knowledge of reporters I do not know, since the New York reporter is decidedly aggressive.” Upon his return to New York, Verner took the chimpanzees and snakes to the Brooklyn Zoological Park and Ota Benga accompanied him. The Zoo’s Director, Dr. W. T. Hornaday, took great interest in the Pygmy and offered him quarters and a job at the Zoo taking care of the chimpanzees, as the keeper of the monkey house had recently quit. Dr. Hornaday thought Ota Benga would be well acquainted with the monkeys and apes and therefore better able to understand their needs. The chimpanzees and their new keeper quickly became famous at the Zoo, but not all the publicity was favorable. The Zoo unwisely decided to exhibit the Pygmy, putting him in a cage with an orangutan, and soon there were objections, especially from Black ministers, and the newspapers raised questions of evolution and race relations. Finally, complaining that no one could understand the Pygmy, Dr. Hornaday sent for Verner to take Ota Benga away. He was placed at first in an orphanage in Brooklyn, an arrangement he readily agreed to when he learned that it was coeducational. He could take a wife back to the Congo with him, he declared, to teach books to his people. But that did not work out either, as Ota Benga was more advanced in years than his size indicated and he did not take to education. The orphanage Director found a job for him on a Long Island potato farm where he was able to save some of his wages for use on his return home. But when it was suggested to him that he might return with Verner to the Congo on his next trip, Ota Benga expressed his wish to remain in America.

A Baptist organization arranged for Ota Benga to attend a school in the South and after that he worked in a tobacco factory. Perhaps the problems of adjusting to a new environment became too much for him, for in 1916, some ten years after arriving in America, Ota Benga sent a bullet through his heart. Verner, quoted in a newspaper article, declared afterward that he

… never understood [Ota Benga’s] mental attitude, but he was one of the most determined little fellows that ever breathed. Possibly he was trying to prove all the time that he was not a Pygmy, as that term even in Africa always conveys the idea of inferiority. I never addressed him as one. To me he was very human, a brave, shrewd little man who preferred to match himself against civilization rather than be a slave to the Bashilele. [New York Times, July 16, 1916.]

Verner also brought an ethnographic collection for the Academy of Sciences in Davenport, Iowa, which he had been engaged to do by W. C. Putnam. Now he offered the same organization the additional collection he had made and had tried to sell to the American Museum; but the Davenport Academy lacked the funds to acquire it. He then offered the collection to the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago. In a letter to Verner the Curator, George A. Dorsey, agreed to examine a catalog that Verner had prepared and to take the matter up with his Board of Directors if the price seemed reasonable. Though none of the museums mentioned above acquired this further collection that Verner had made expressly in order to sell it, it clearly appears that he had prepared a catalog of it and, presumably, eventually did dispose of it. So far, its location remains a mystery.

The botanical explorations that Verner undertook in the Kasai were apparently very successful, for Verner was congratulated by the Director of the Missouri Botanical Garden for bringing a large number of live plants back from Central Africa.

Verner the Developer

The reports that Verner received on the mineral collections that he had sold to the Smithsonian encouraged him to keep an eye out for interesting deposits. While traveling through Lele and Pende country collecting artifacts for Frederick Starr, Verner noted the presence of many crystals in a river bed and recorded this fact in his notebook — but in the Luba language for reasons of secrecy. The site was on the Tschikapa River, a tributary of the Kasai that joins it above Wissmann Falls (the location of the rapids that block navigation for river steamers coming up from the Congo), and hence in an area that had been little visited by Whites. Because he did not have license to prospect for diamonds and feared the consequences if he were to find and carry any away, Verner made no attempt to search for gemstones at the time. Also, he had an obligation to return to his permanent camp where Starr was waiting for him. Verner by now was well aware of the desire of the Belgian King to develop the mineral potential of the region; and he was also mindful of the struggle going on among the western European powers for colonial territory in Africa. Before Starr arrived, Verner had been visited at his camp near Ndombe by the famous specialist in African ethnology and art history, Leo Frobenius, but took the real purpose of the German’s visit to be other than academic.

Nominally commissioned to make ethnic collections for the Berlin Museum, he came to my headquarters at Mt. Washington and, by his actions and conversation, convinced me that he was really seeking to discover the economic resources of the region there, in the line between German South-West Africa and German East Africa, with a view looking to dismemberment of the Belgian Congo and obtaining a continuous strip of territory across Africa. [Letter, Verner to Mrs. McGee, August 19, 1936.]

Conspiring with the Bikenge King to divert Frobenius from the valuable mineral deposits on the upper Kasai, Verner and Ndombe directed Frobenius to the country of the Bena Mbindu (Bindundu) where they expected Frobenius’ party to lose its way. Frobenius, however, successfully entered the lands of the Pende and the Chokwe and eventually reached Pogge Falls (near Mai Munene) on the upper Kasai [Frobenius, 1907, pp. 242-349]. The international agreements in force at the time were supposed to give all the Western European powers the right to participate in the development of the Congo; but the Belgians feared the Germans and were pleased when Verner reported that he had thwarted an effort that might have given the Germans a claim to a concession on the Kasai. Verner himself, of course, hoped to play a role in the development of the region that he had come to know so well. On his trips through Brussels he conferred with King Leopold II and with officials of the government, urging them to grant concessions to American interests in the upper Kasai region, both to further its development and to preempt it from other interests.

After returning from his third trip to Africa, Verner, in August of 1906, went to New York to talk with American financiers about his ideas for the commercial development of the Congo. He had become increasingly confident that what was needed to raise the standard of living for the Congolese and to make the region return a profit for its developers was American capital, American engineering knowledge, and American ingenuity. Now, with extensive experience in the country, and having himself experimented with methods of collecting wild rubber, he could speak with authority. At about the same time, the American financier, Thomas F. Ryan, who was vacationing in Switzerland, was invited by King Leopold to confer with him in Brussels. They soon came to an agreement on the formation of two companies to be financed largely with American capital — the Société Internationale Forestière et Minière du Congo (also called the “Forminière”) and the American Congo Company. Ryan brought in some associates — the Guggenheims, Bernard Baruch, Edward B. Aldrich, and others. Verner gained an introduction to some of these gentlemen and in January of 1907 he was engaged by the American Congo Company and charged to return to Africa to direct the search for sources of native rubber. Verner had hoped to have a voice in the selection of the region in which the exploration was to be undertaken, but he found that the concession had already been made — a large tract on the left bank of the Congo River about sixty miles above Kinshasa and thirty-five miles below the mouth of the Kasai (Kwamouth). A rubber collecting station was established at a place named Mt. Cleveland, after the American President. Verner’s energies were wholly consumed with the problems of erecting buildings, exploring for rubber, recruiting labor, and keeping all those who were employed on the project healthy. The region, Verner later wrote, was very thinly populated by emaciated and weakened tribes (the BaMfinu or BaMfumungu). Though there is no mention in Verner’s papers of ethnographic collections made in this region, in an unpublished manuscript entitled, Empire Building in Central Africa, Verner does provide some information about local methods of fishing and collecting rubber.

The geological exploring team, put into the field by the other American-backed company, the Forminière, included a young engineer, Sydney H. Ball, whom Verner encouraged to join the expedition, was led by an old Congo hand and former U.S. agent who had been stationed in the region, R. Dorsey Mohun, who had become deeply involved in the internal affairs of the country. To this group Verner revealed his knowledge of mineral deposits in the Tschikapa River valley, a hint that proved immensely valuable to the Company. Their explorations bore out Verner’s suggestions, with the first diamonds being discovered at Mai Munene, “Big Water,” a waterfall on the upper Kasai River. Subsequently a great diamond-mining establishment sprang up at Tschikapa, with American engineers and managers who were depending heavily upon local labor.

The story of Verner’s last involvement in the Congo, in this rubber and mineral exploring activities, is only scantily documented in his papers deposited in the South Caroliniana Library. He stayed with the American Congo Company only about a year. In 1912, some years after he had left the rubber-collecting venture and had taken a position in Panama, Verner, in a letter to the Director of the New York Zoological Garden, explained the termination of his involvement in the Congo enterprise:

I shall not attempt here to refer to the reasons why I left them [the Company] in detail, as it would require a long and involved statement; but, boiled down, it is this: King Leopold failed to carry out his pledges to me to institute certain reforms which I regarded as essential to any permanent success there. Without them, I regarded it as useless to go on further. At the same time, the New York principals would risk losing their concession if they offended the King, as it was idle to expect the American government to back them up, particularly as Mr. [Theodore] Roosevelt had taken so pronounced an attitude of hostility to certain of them. Hence I saw that I had to efface myself temporarily in order to let them keep in with the King. This may explain why I quit writing about African matters — or at least partly explain it — the other reason being that I was busy mastering a new science and doing things down here [in Panama].

The Verner Collections

Verner sold part (perhaps most) of his first ethnographic collection, along with some zoological and mineralogical specimens, to the Smithsonian Institution in 1899 for $200. The two-hundred and fifty or so artifacts all come from the period 1896-99 when he was associated with the Presbyterian Mission. The ethnic attributions recorded in the ledgers of the Department of Anthropology, where the collection is curated, were doubtless provided by Verner and are limited to BaLuba, BaKuba, BaTwa (Pygmy), BaNgala, and Zapo-Zap. Subsequent study has shown some of the items to be of styles now generally attributed to certain other ethnic groups, namely, the Biombo, Teke, Songye, Pende, and Luluwa — all peoples living in or close to the region where Verner labored. At the time of his first trip, Verner may have considered most of these latter groups to be mere subdivisions of the larger and better-known tribes, to which some of them were subject.

The Starr collection deposited in the American Museum of Natural History in New York City, is much larger, numbering some 4000 items. It appears from Starr’s field notebooks that more than 1200 of these were collected for him by Verner in 1905, though this is not apparent in the papers accompanying the collection. The Verner collection at the Putnam Museum in Davenport, Iowa, obtained also during his third trip to Central Africa in 1905-06, consists of some sixty-four items representing several Kasai tribal styles.

For the main part (with the probable exception of the showy Zapo-Zap battle-axes which were already being produced in quantity to sell as souvenirs) the artifacts that Verner acquired were entirely authentic. However, even at that early date a market for “fetishes” was developing, encouraged, says Starr, especially by Frobenius, who paid higher prices than other collectors. Starr writes that he refused to buy most of the masks and figurines that had been freshly made, preferring the older examples. Yet many items in the collection that he sent to the American Museum do look newly carved.

Returning to the queries posed at the opening, it appears that Verner acquired the objects that he subsequently sold to public museums in the United States by trading goods and services for them at rates acceptable to the owners, a procedure deemed wholly legitimate and ethical at the time. Frobenius’ account of the readiness of the Bikenge to trade their masks, figures, and ornamental containers for salt, cloth, and hoe blades confirms Verner’s report about commercialism in the area. Starr’s field notes lend further support. Markets for foodstuffs and other utilitarian goods were already flourishing; and if they were not already being sold, ritual objects were apparently readily included in goods considered salable when the demand emerged. While neither Frobenius, Starr, nor Verner raised ethical questions concerning the purchase of religious emblems or ritual paraphernalia that might have been communal property, it is clear that for them to have done so would have run counter to their primary purposes. And so that question, at least, remains unanswered.

References

I. Published Works

Bennitt, Mark, and Frank P. Stockbridge. History of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition: St. Louis, 1905.

Cornet, J. A Survey of Zairian Art. Raleigh, NC, 1978.

Frobenius, Leo. Im Schatten des Kingostaates. Berlin, 1907.

Himmelheber, Hans. Negerkunst und Negerkünstler. Braunschweig, 1960.

Sheppard, William H. Pioneers in Congo. Louisville, 1916.

de Sousberghe, L. L’Art Pende. Brussels, 1958.

Starr, Frederick. Congo Natives. Chicago, 1912.

Verner, Samuel Phillips. A letter dated September 15, 1898, in “Letters from the Field” in The Missionary. Nashville, January 1899, pp. 26-28.

____ “Dombi — A Character Sketch,” in The Missionary, June 1899, pp. 275-77.

____ “Woman in Africa,” in The Missionary, August 1899, pp. 374-78.

____ Pioneering in Central Africa. Richmond, VA, 1903.

____ “The Yellow Men of Africa,” in American Anthropologist, 5, 1903, pp. 539-44.

____ “Adventures of an Explorer in Africa,” in Harper’s Weekly, 48, 1904, pp. 1618-1620.

II. Unpublished Works

Accession records for the Verner and Starr collections in the American Museum of Natural History, in the Smithsonian Institution, and in the Putnam Museum, Davenport, IA.

Crawford, John R. The Instructive Missionary Career of Samuel Phillips Verner, a manuscript in the Samuel Phillips Verner Papers, South Caroliniana Library, Columbia, SC.

The William John McGee Papers in the Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

The Frederick Starr Papers in the Regenstern Library of the University of Chicago, Chicago, IL.

The Samuel Phillips Verner Papers in the South Caroliniana Library, Columbia, SC.

Verner, Samuel Phillips. The Travels of Ntoka, a manuscript in the Samuel Phillips Verner Papers, South Caroliniana Library, Columbia, SC.

____ Autobiography. A manuscript in the Samuel Phillips Verner papers.

Starr, who also writes about Ndombe’s basis for acceding to the chieftainship, says that Ndombe’s “… mother was Bashilele, and that he was recognized as Chief by the lesser Bashilele chiefs of his area.” [Starr, 1912: p. 15.]

However, the Annual Report of the Executive Committee of Foreign Missions of the Presbyterian Church in the United States (Southern) for 1898 includes the following statement: “In March, 1897, Mr. Verner, with the approval of Messrs. Sheppard and Hawkins, made a trip to the Wissmann Falls country to investigate the matter of opening a new station, the Committee having sanctioned the opening of two new stations.”