 |
STEREO REVIEW, November 1997
Here is a close-knit group that continues to produce splendid chamber jazz but
somehow manages to elude the big spotlight. Five Concerts and a Landscape was
recorded at appearances in and around New York between 1992 and 1995. Pianist
Larry Bluth, bassist Don Messina and drummer Bill Chattin move authoratively
through a program of nine familiar selections and a Messina original, "The
Dean's List."
Chris Albertson
JAZZ EDUCATORS JOURNAL, May 1998
An
extraordinary trio suffused with glowing passion and caringness in its
fresh, spirited music. Devout disciples of legendary pianist
Lennie Tristano's unconventional music, this trio also reflects some
traces of Bud Powell. The three thread their own attractive
melodic contributions to the long, ranging lines of improvisations
characteristic of Tristano . . . Like the trio's
impressive debut on Live At
Orfeo, they chose the ambient live
New York-area settings to precipitate a true blue genuine CD.
For example, tap the sheer purity of their oeuvre by listening
to "You Go To My Head," "You Stepped Out Of A Dream,"
or "Darn That Dream." What a joyful groove to hear
how very familiar tunes and chord progressions are fluidly redeveloped!
Discover refreshment in open turf. Experience the
striking equilibrium between looseness and tautness. Be mindful this is
authoritative music played by musicians who insist on propagating swing.
The triangle of Bluth, Messina, and Chattin is rare excitement.
Dr. Herb Wong
JAZZ TIMES, March 1998
These two CDs of live recordings [Live at Orfeo and Five Concerts
and a Landscape] represent a team approach in many respects, ncluding the recording style:
The Masters were prepared using a stereo pair of microphones, and the full ambiance of the
setting pervades each track. More importantly, the musical balance is a matter of the
sensitvities of the musicians in the moment. Such a recording makes a statement as to the
intentions of the artists that should not be ignorned in assessing their work. The results
support the statement . . Messina and Chattin are solid and sensitive accompanists to Bluth... Bluth's harmonic sense dominates the arrangements, creating shadows that seem to put even the
most familiar chord progressions in a new perspective - an effect that's heightened by the
somewhat muted ambiance of the recordings. As to the material, Live At Orfeo is mostly
originals, Five Concerts mostly standards, but even the standards seem created to
sustain the trio dynamic established in Live At Orfeo's opener: Empathy.
Bill Bennet
WIRED, November 1997
It's one thing to play classic jazz, something sadder to replay it. Yet while
this three-some's sound may recall celebrated acoustic triads of the . . . '50s, the inventive
improvisations keep their music from feeling like a retro trip.
Bluth peps ups Miles's "Little Willie Leaps" with some playful piano while Messina intricately
solos over Chattin's trancey rhythms in "Lover Come Back To Me."
Just as they did on their equally wonderful debut, Live at Orfeo, Bluth, Messina and
Chattin
make music as classic as the guys who inspired them.
Paul Semel
GREEN MOUNTAIN JAZZ MESSENGER, April
1998
The selections on Larry Bluth's second Zinnia album,
Five Concerts and a Landscape were recorded live in concerts over a three year period
around New York City. (The landscape, reproduced as cover illustration, is a painting by
Annette Bluth-Lukemire to whom the CD is dedicated in memoriam)... Interpretations are very much by the rules of the Lennie Tristano school.
Lengthly linear exposition and improvisation, maintenance of a steady medium to up-tempo pace
by a rhythm section, mininimal inflection: all add up to an even-tempered approach to the
material. Such a technique for better or worse, can operate
as a sure safeguard against emotional excess, yielding for example a "You Stepped Out Of A
Dream" devoid of romance, or a relatively dry "Get Happy."
... Formal perfection, immaculate phrasing and tight ensemble work are here in abundance,
perhaps most strikingly on the more relaxed numbers, "You Go To My Head" and
"Darn That Dream." And throughout, Messina and Chattin demonstrate rare compatibility,
particularly noticeable on the fours. Collectively, these tunes mirror
the subdued colors, distinct lines, and cool beauty of the Bluth-Lukemire landscape on the
cover.
Given its virtues, this release is sure to please devotees of the piano trio format and
encourage listeners to check out this group's earlier Live At Orfeo.
Lou Kannenstine
VICTORY REVIEW, November 1997
Their performances of these jazz standards have the welded-together feel that
only comes from long experience with the intimacy of playing together live. Bluth breathes life
into "My Melancholy Baby" and "Get Happy." The only complaint is that there isn't enough
of Messina's graceful bass. His solo on "Lover Come Back To Me," and his intro to "The Dean's
List," a Messina original, whet our appetite for more.
Todd De Groff
JAZZ CANADIANA, September 1997
http://www.idbt.com/jazzcdn/ppsept97.htm
In their second release, a compendium of five concerts, . . . the trio
restricts itself almost exclusively to a range of standard material; however, there is nothing
stale about the musical treatment of familiar tunes in the hands of this threesome. Many of the
selections begin in a straightforward manner, establishing the recognizable melody, then
fragmenting it, or toying around its periphery, seemingly pursuing it before drawing it back
for the closing, "My Melcancholy Baby," "Lover Come Back To Me," "Darn That Dream." Here, too,
the bass and drums are given more prominent roles, most noticeably on the final cut, "I'll
Remember April" . . . It's a trio I would like to see in performance.
Jonathan Sutherland
CADENCE, September 1997
If you favor solid bebop - as an idiom for ideas and musical
invention . . . try this document of a working band going about their
business. Selections from live concerts showcase this trio at their most
limber and inspired. As an ensemble, they really click in "I'll
Remember April" and bass player Don Messina's "The Dean's
List," featuring him in a series of exchanges with drummer Bill
Chattin. Messina and Chattin are sturdy, dependable soloists. A real
delight is Larry Bluth's inventive piano . . . there's a refreshing
sense of engagement with the idiom, a commitment to fresh ideas that
shows how he's absorbed primary lessons from such very different players
as Powell and Tristano. Recommended.
David Lewis
Jazz Central Station
Opening of "My Melancholy Baby" sets the pace on this wickedly well-played
and surprising live trio date from pianist Larry Bluth, bassist Don Messina
and drummer Bill Chattin. An ensemble group which has played together for
over ten years, recording is jazz for the serious jazz fan: intricate,
original and consistently swinging. An evolution from the Lennie
Tristano-style, Bluth's piano styling consists of what could be called a
traditional bebop style inflected with surprising, deceptively complex
musical fantasies and atypical directions from chordal predictability. Just
when you think you've got it figured out, the ensemble slips into a
different gear, playing harmonic mind games and leading the way to musical
mazes. Repertoire consists of jazz standards throughout, daring to find
meaning in "Get Happy," "Love Me or Leave Me" and "Darn that Dream" astonishingly, without
cliches.
Rick Marx
OTTAWA CITIZEN, May 1998
Pianist Bluth, bassist Messina and drummer Chattin... know how to express themselves as individuals and as a unit... this trio burrows deep inside the songs, finds the essence andmakes the listener hear the compositions in new ways.
Five Concerts and a Landscape... offers satisfying reassurance
that communication on a deep level is still alive and well in jazz.
and surprising live trio date from pianist Larry Bluth, bassist Don Messina
James Hale
ALL ABOUT JAZZ, August 1998
http://www.allaboutjazz.com/index.html
The title to this one derives from the five concerts where these ten
selections were recorded; the landscape, by the late Annette
Bluth-Lukemire, to whom this disc is dedicated, is on the front cover.
Most of the cuts are the sorts of standards favored by Tristano-school
players like Warne Marsh and Lee Konitz; pianist Bluth, backed by the
bass of Messina and the drums of Chattin, plays them in Konitzian
manner, sweetly and brightly, but with daring and piquant harmonies
that might slip right by you if you're not paying attention. This sort of
playing transfixed performers like Anthony Braxton, who emulates it on
his standards recordings and shows marks of it in all his work. Braxton
once described the effect of listening to a new Warne Marsh record after
a steady diet of Coltrane, Ayler and Coleman: he said that coming from
that perspective, he couldn't hear it, but that Marsh was playing things
that were just as "out" as these outcats.
That's what this disc is like. From one angle, it's a pleasant
collection of songs like "My Melancholy Baby," "You Go to My Head,"
"Lover Come Back to Me," "You Stepped Out of a Dream," "Darn That
Dream," and "I'll Remember April." As if the world needed more
interpretations of those. But Bluth, Messina, and Chattin lay down
grooves that reward those who take the time to listen attentively. On
every track, Bluth takes the songs into uncharted waters, sounding
harmonically a bit like Martial Solal, who has recorded some memorable
standards with Konitz, over the rhythm section's cool and upbeat
background all the while.
On the basis of Bluth's adventurous but never grating playing, this
disc is worth hearing. The sound quality of these live club tracks
leaves much to be desired, but the music is there for anyone who
listens.
Robert Spencer
|